Read Time: 7 minutes

Why Insurance Companies Need Localized Marketing


The vast majority of Americans have some kind of insurance. More than 95 percent of homeowners have a form of home insurance, and 88 percent of drivers have some configuration of auto insurance.


With so many insurance types and companies out there, it can be challenging for your insurance company and local insurance agents to get noticed. One way to rise above competitors is to have a localized marketing strategy.


In this article, we’ll explain what localized marketing is, the different aspects of it, and how each works together to help your local insurance agents and brokers gain more clients and increase their revenue. We’ll also explain how SOCi’s software and solutions can help automate your insurance marketing strategy while helping you stay on brand and compliant with regulators.


What is Localized Marketing?


Before going further, we need to define localized marketing. Localized marketing is the practice of creating and implementing a marketing strategy that is distributed at the local level. It’s understanding and meeting the needs of local customers and communities. 


The three main components of localized marketing are local search, online reputation management, and local social.


Below, we’ll further explain what each of these localized marketing categories entail and tactics your local agents can implement to enhance their localized marketing efforts.


1. Invest in Local Search


Local search, commonly called local SEO (search engine optimization), is the process of optimizing your website and online presence to increase visibility on search engines and attain more online traffic from consumers.


One way local insurance agents can improve their local search rankings is by optimizing their local listings.


Optimize Your Local Listings


If you don’t already know, local listings are business profiles of your local insurance company or agent that appear on search engines and local directories like Google, Yelp, or Facebook.

When people search for local insurance providers or companies, local listings often appear on the search engine results page (SERP).

Example of an insurance agency’s Google Business Profile in the local finder with a map in the background overlaid on a laptop

Local agencies and agents ranking at the top of the SERP gain a significant advantage over local competitors. We found that the top three Google Business Profiles (GBPs), which are the local listings on Google, receive 126 percent more traffic and 93 percent more conversion-oriented actions than businesses ranked 4-10.


Optimizing your GBP and other local listings means having complete profiles with essential information consumers seek, such as:

  • Name, address, and phone number (NAP)
  • Directions to your local office
  • Links to your website and local social profiles
  • Hours of operations
  • Provided services
  • High-quality photos and videos
  • Categories
  • Description


Having this accurate business information will help your GBPs and other local listings rank on search engines and local directories when consumers search for “insurance agency near me” or “insurance agent Denver.”


Make Local Search Easier With a Local Listings Solution


One issue insurance companies and their agent’s face is managing their listings across dozens of local directories. Make local listings management easier with SOCi Listings

Our local listings solution can help improve your local SEO by ensuring you have all the necessary information filled out on each listing. Plus, SOCi GeoRank, our map-based keyword reporting software, helps your insurance company and agents gain insight into how their offices stack up against competitors for the most important keywords.

A product image showcasing SOCi GeoRank


2. Participate in Online Reputation Management


The second pillar of localized marketing is online reputation management (ORM). ORM at the local level is the process of monitoring and influencing what’s being said about local insurance agents or brokers.


A lot of ORM deals with gaining, monitoring, and responding to reviews.


Gain Client Testimonials and Reviews


Gaining reviews for your local listings can help with your ORM, local search rankings, and conversion rate.


Reviews help your local listings, like your GBP, rank higher on search engines. According to local SEO experts, two of the top local search ranking factors are high numerical ratings and the quantity of reviews with text.


Ratings and reviews also improve conversion rates. Our research shows that conversion improves by 44 percent when a GBP increases its average star rating by one full star.


It’s evident that agents should work towards getting as many positive reviews on their local listings as possible. Here are a few ways agents can acquire more reviews.


Green heading with white numbered text list stating four way to gain more reviews on a dark blue background.


Monitor and Respond to Reviews


Another aspect of ORM is monitoring and responding to reviews. Current clients want to be well taken care of and responded to while potential clients want to ensure they receive the same treatment. 


Responding to reviews shows current and future clients that you care about their feedback and look to improve your local insurance agency. Furthermore, we found responding to reviews also boosts conversions. For every 25 reviews responded to, conversion on GBPs improves by 4.1 percent.

Download our Multi-Location Marketers Guide to Online Reputation Management for detailed strategies on how to manage and respond to reviews.


CTA for the Online Reputation Management Guide for Multi-Location Marketers


Employ Software to Streamline Your Reputation Management 


If your corporate team and local insurance agents are having a difficult time managing and responding to reviews in a timely manner, consider using SOCi Reviews


Our reviews software uses sentiment analysis technology to track how clients perceive different agencies and agents, which helps corporate and local teams identify areas of improvement. 

Furthermore, you can use SOCi Reviews to respond quickly to customers. Our integration with Open AI’s ChatGPT uses machine learning algorithms to provide fast and accurate responses to clients in real time. It’s worth noting that as an insurance company, a human touch is still needed to ensure the response falls within compliance guidelines.

An iphone, ipad, and computer screen highlighting SOCi's reviews solution

3. Utilize Local Social


The third and final aspect of localized marketing for insurance companies is local social, sometimes referred to as localized social. Local social is when individual agents have their own local social media profiles and publish on them to generate new leads and retain customers.


Localized content receives 12x the engagement compared to non-localized content. Therefore, it’s imperative that insurance companies have a local social strategy.


Types of Local Social Content


In general, your local social agents should each have their own social pages and publish engaging and interactive content. Understanding your agents’ target audience and demographics will help determine which social platforms to put the most energy towards. That said, Facebook is a must, with 2.96 billion monthly users worldwide. Here’s an example of an insurance company’s local Facebook post:

A picture of a young man giving a thumbs up inside a car and holding a green piggy bank with a Facebook caption written above and Money Saving Tips in white in the bottom right corner.

Below are some local social content ideas your local insurance agents can publish:


Live Q&A sessions: Host an Instagram or Facebook Live where you answer followers’ insurance-related questions. These sessions are a great way to show your expertise and build trust with potential and existing clients.


Quizzes and Polls: Generate local quizzes and polls. You can have followers vote on their favorite places to visit in a city. You can also ask insurance-related questions like, “How much do you think the insurance rate in [state] differs for these four age groups?” These quizzes, polls, and answers can be stand-alone posts or featured stories. 


Insurance myth-busters and must-know terms: Share a series of social media posts, like a Twitter thread, that debunk common insurance myths. Or, you can list essential insurance terms consumers need to know. 


Testimonials and user-generated content (UGC): Eight in ten consumers say UGC highly impacts their purchase decisions. With clients’ permission, publish written or video testimonials. Just ensure they’re the actual statements from customers, per FTC guidelines.


Employee spotlights: Publish employee success stories or “get to know you” posts to help acquaint followers with your staff.


Giveaways and contests: Host contests or giveaways such as a gift card to a local restaurant or a free consultation if you like and share the post.


For additional tips on creating a robust local social strategy for your insurance company, download our Localized Social Content Guide for Financial Services Companies.



To help corporate teams and local insurance agents publish social content, you need SOCi Social. Our shared libraries and calendars can help your multi-location insurance company manage and schedule localized content across multiple branches on major social networks.


Our social solution also has built-in social compliance functionalities that help your local agents’ social posts stay on brand and policy compliant. More on these features in the next section!


Ensure Branded and Compliant Content


Like other industries, insurance companies want their local agents to publish branded content. However, unlike other industries, your insurance company must adhere to more rigorous FINRA, NAIC, and state regulations.


It’s challenging ensuring that 100 or 1,000s of insurance agents adhere to these different regulations and guidelines. As mentioned, your corporate and local teams can strengthen oversight, mitigate compliance risks, and consolidate efforts with SOCi’s social compliance features.


Below are some of the main social compliance features within our social solution:


Keyword policies: Our keyword policies can help minimize the potential for compliance violations and ensure local agents follow brand guidelines when posting social content or updating social profiles. 


Real-time push notifications: These notifications sent via SMS-text or email can increase oversight and allow corporate teams to adjust the content that violates corporate, state, or federal guidelines.


Record of social media activity: In-house archiving allows insurance companies to quickly export activity logs and provide stakeholders with detailed information during an audit, merger, or acquisition.


Improve Your Insurance Marketing With SOCi


As you can see, there’s a lot to manage regarding insurance marketing at the local level. Make your localized marketing easier by partnering with a software company built for multi-location companies.


SOCi’s local listings, reviews, and social solutions can help automate your corporate and local agents’ daily marketing activities. This consolidation gives you more time to focus on supporting your clients.

Working together, our products also give you corporate oversight and help reduce compliance issues and risks. Request a demo today to learn how we can help improve your insurance marketing efforts!



CTA Button - Request Demo

Chi Whitley

Chi Whitley is a content marketer who specializes in local SEO. He’s passionate about helping multi-location businesses grow their brands and online presence in the ever-changing world of localized marketing.

Learn how SOCi can help take your
localized marketing to the next level.